Are Cleansing Balms (Like Elemis Pro-Collagen) Better Than Cleansing Oils
Table of contents
The Biggest Makeup Mistake Happens After You Take It Off
The single biggest makeup mistake you can make has nothing to do with your application technique; it’s about not removing your makeup properly at the end of the day. Leftover foundation and sunscreen can clog pores, lead to breakouts, and create a rough, uneven surface for your makeup the next morning. The professional solution? The Double Cleanse.
The first and most crucial step of this method is using an oil-based cleanser to melt away makeup. The two main champions in this category are the luxurious Cleansing Balm and the efficient Cleansing Oil.
They both do a similar job, but their formulas and the experience they provide are completely different. We’re putting these two head-to-head to see which is better for you, and to find out if luxe balms like the famous Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm are truly a superior choice.
The Science: “Like Dissolves Like”
The fundamental principle here is simple chemistry: “like dissolves like.” The oils in a cleansing balm or oil are lipophilic, meaning they are attracted to other oils. They grab onto the oil-based molecules in your foundation, concealer, sunscreen, and even waterproof mascara, effectively dissolving them in a way a water-based cleanser cannot do alone.
The Case for Cleansing Balms: The Luxurious Spa Experience
The Philosophy & How It Works
A cleansing balm is a solid-to-oil formula that is solid at room temperature. You scoop a small amount, warm it between your dry fingertips until it transforms into a rich oil, and then massage it onto your dry face.
The Pros
- Less Messy & Travel-Friendly: Its solid form makes it perfect for travel—there is zero risk of it spilling or leaking in your bag.
- Encourages Facial Massage: The thick, cushiony texture is perfect for a proper facial massage, which helps to increase circulation and can be a wonderful, stress-relieving part of your night routine.
- Luxurious Feel: High-end balms, like the iconic Elemis Pro-Collagen, often include beautiful aromatic botanicals, turning your daily cleanse into a spa-like, sensory experience.
The Cons
- Generally more expensive per ounce than cleansing oils.
- Scooping the product from a jar can feel less hygienic to some compared to a pump.
The Case for Cleansing Oils: The Quick & Efficient Clean
The Philosophy & How It Works
A cleansing oil starts as a liquid, typically housed in a pump bottle. You pump the oil directly into your dry hands and massage it onto your dry face.
The Pros
- Quick and Easy Dispensing: A pump is fast, hygienic, and dispenses the perfect amount every time.
- Often Rinses Cleaner: Many cleansing oils are formulated with emulsifiers that cause the oil to turn into a milky liquid upon contact with water. This allows them to rinse away completely without leaving any greasy residue behind.
- Cost-Effective: In general, there are more affordable, high-quality options available in the cleansing oil category.
The Cons
- The thin, liquid texture can be messy, dripping through your fingers.
- They are not ideal for travel, as the pumps can sometimes leak.
The At-a-Glance Comparison Table
Feature | Cleansing Balm (e.g., Elemis) | Cleansing Oil |
Texture | Solid-to-Oil | Liquid Oil |
Experience | Luxurious, Spa-like, Massage | Fast, Efficient, Clean-Rinsing |
Travel-Friendliness | Excellent | Fair (Risk of Leaks) |
Application | Mess-Free | Can be Drippy |
Best For | A relaxing night routine | A quick and effective cleanse |
The Verdict: It’s a Matter of Texture, Not Efficacy
So, are cleansing balms better than cleansing oils? In terms of pure cleansing efficacy, no. Both are exceptionally effective at dissolving stubborn makeup and sunscreen.
The choice between them is purely a matter of personal preference and lifestyle. Do you crave a luxurious, mindful, spa-like ritual at the end of your day? Choose a balm. Do you prioritize speed, efficiency, and a super-clean rinse? Choose an oil.
The most important takeaway is that you choose one of them as the first step in your nightly skincare routine. Doing so fixes the biggest makeup mistake—sleeping with makeup on—and provides a perfectly clean, healthy canvas for the flawless base you want to create tomorrow.